First of all, the most critical piece of LJ and internet etiquette there is: Talking about your own wild theories is a wonderful thing, but if you're talking about actual rumors that you've heard from, like, actual interviews, or wherever people get their rumors from, WARN FOR SPOILERS. Seriously, you don't want to be in the middle of the hell that's going to break loose if someone who's already in a pissy mood accidentally gets spoiled. (I should know - I just about strangled the person who spoiled me for Dumbledore's death.)
Um, if I misread your post, and those rumors are just other people having wild theories, sorry.
That said, I love love love the Dumbledore as a phoenix animagus theory, it makes perfect sense, and I'd be really happy if it turned out to be true.
tinnny is pretty convinced that Harry is a horcrux. Personally, I haven't read the books in so long that I barely remember how the things were supposed to work, never mind remembering any foreshadowing as to who/where they could be, so I don't know. You think they could both be horcruxes, or would that be over the top?
I'm convinced that Snape will turn out to be one of the good guys, and that he'll die, probably while saving Harry's live. Fifty percent chance of Harry dying, too, at the very least. There's a good chance that Sirius might return, I think, but only if Harry survives the end of the book, too.
no subject
Um, if I misread your post, and those rumors are just other people having wild theories, sorry.
That said, I love love love the Dumbledore as a phoenix animagus theory, it makes perfect sense, and I'd be really happy if it turned out to be true.
I'm convinced that Snape will turn out to be one of the good guys, and that he'll die, probably while saving Harry's live. Fifty percent chance of Harry dying, too, at the very least. There's a good chance that Sirius might return, I think, but only if Harry survives the end of the book, too.